PHMSA Pre-empts FDNY Hazmat Permit Fee

Posted on 7/7/2017 by Roger Marks

In the Federal Register yesterday, the US DOT Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) announced that the Federal Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR) in some cases pre-empt hazmat inspection and permit rules created by the New York City Fire Department.

FDNY Hazmat Inspection and Permit Requirements

For carriers based outside of FDNY’s jurisdiction, this action invalidates the FDNY hazmat transportation inspection and permit requirements at FC 2707.4 and 105.6. So, if you are outside of New York City, you are not subject to these FDNY hazmat inspection and permit requirements.

Motor carriers based within New York City are subject to FDNY’s jurisdiction, however, and therefore must still comply with the FDNY vehicle inspection and permit requirements

FDNY Hazmat Permit Fee

FDNY requires motor vehicle carriers to obtain a permit to transport certain quantities of flammable liquids, combustible liquids, compressed gases, and explosives within the city.

PHMSA has now determined that this is not a “fair” fee and states that FDNY has failed to prove that the fee is “used for a purpose related to transporting hazardous materials,” as required by 49 USC 5125(f)(1). Therefore, PHMSA has chosen to pre-empt the FDNY hazmat fee, rendering it unenforceable at least for the time being.  

Legal Challenge to FDNY Hazmat Rules

The legal challenge to FDNY’s hazmat rules was brought by the American Trucking Association (ATA), which argued on behalf of carriers that the additional hazmat inspection and permit requirements created an undue time and cost burden. Further, it made it difficult for carriers to comply with PHMSA’s 49 CFR regulations, which require hazardous materials to be “transported without unnecessary delay.” [49 CFR 177.88(d)]

What Is Federal Preemption Under Hazmat Transportation Law?

Federal agencies like US DOT may “pre-empt” or invalidate State or local laws or regulations when those State rules conflict with or encourage noncompliance with Federal requirements.
In this case, PHMSA “found that the City created its own independent set of cargo containment, equipment and related requirements that overlap extensive HMR requirements, are likely to encourage noncompliance with the HMR, and concern subjects that [PHMSA] has determined are its exclusive province under the HMTA.”

To see the Federal pre-emption rules for hazardous materials, see 49 U.S.C. 5125

North Jersey Hazmat Training in August 

If you ship hazardous materials in the greater NYC area, meet your DOT, IATA, and IMDG training mandates with trusted training at Lion’s new Training Center in Sparta, NJ!

On August 15–17, get recurrent 49 CFR training, IATA DGR training, and IMDG Code training that covers the latest requirements that impact your shipments. Whether you ship by the bottle, the box, the pallet, or the truckload, learn a simple step-by-step approach to keep hazmat in compliance with the latest domestic and international rules.

Or check out for a list of popular hazmat, hazardous waste, EPA, and OSHA online training solutions.  

Tags: hazmat, inspection, NYC, PHMSA, shipping

Find a Post

Compliance Archives

Lion - Quotes

Amazing instructor; real-life examples. Lion training gets better every year!

Frank Papandrea

Environmental Manager

I have been to other training companies, but Lion’s material is much better and easier to understand.

Mark Abell

Regional Manager

I used the IT support number available and my issue was resolved within a few minutes. I don't see anything that could have made it better.

Danny Province

EHS Professional

Lion courses are the standard to which all other workshops should strive for!

Brody Saleen

Registered Environmental Health Specialist

I can take what I learned in this workshop and apply it to everyday work and relate it to my activities.

Shane Hersh

Materials Handler

The instructor was probably the best I ever had! He made the class enjoyable, was humorous at times, and very knowledgeable.

Mary Sue Michon

Environmental Administrator

The instructor was great, explaining complex topics in terms that were easily understandable and answering questions clearly and thoroughly.

Brittany Holm

Lab Supervisor

The instructor was very dedicated to providing a quality experience. She did her best to make sure students were really comprehending the information.

Stephanie Venn

Inventory Control Specialist

I like Lion's workshops the best because they really dig into the information you need to have when you leave the workshop.

Tom Bush, Jr.

EHS Manager

The instructor made the class enjoyable. He presented in a very knowledgeable, personable manner. Best class I've ever attended. Will take one again.

John Nekoloff

Environmental Compliance Manager

Download Our Latest Whitepaper

In-flight hazmat incidents can be disastrous. This guide gives 5 tips for first-time air shippers to consider before offering dangerous goods for transportation on passenger or cargo aircraft.

Latest Whitepaper

By submitting your phone number, you agree to receive recurring marketing and training text messages. Consent to receive text messages is not required for any purchases. Text STOP at any time to cancel. Message and data rates may apply. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.