Search

Indemnity Clauses and CERCLA Liability

Posted on 9/7/2021 by Anthony Cardno, CHMM

The Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) requires US EPA to identify Superfund sites and determine who is responsible for paying the clean up costs. 

CERCLA identifies four categories of Potentially Responsible Parties or PRPs:
  • The current owner and operator of the site
  • The owner and operator of the site at the time the substances were disposed of
  • Anyone who arranged for the disposal of the substances at the site
  • Anyone who transported the substances to the site
If we think it terms of EPA’s hazardous waste regulations for a moment, those categories cover generators (arranged for disposal), transporters (get it there), and Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities (the contaminated property).

But often, contracts between generators include language that transfers liability in case of legal claims. So how does that affect liability under CERCLA? Can generators use such “hold harmless” or indemnity clauses to get relief from paying to clean up a Superfund site?

The simple answer is No.

What CERCLA Says About Indemnity Clauses and Contracts

CERCLA says “No indemnification, hold harmless, or similar agreement or conveyance shall be effective to transfer from the owner or operator of any vessel or facility or from any person who may be liable for a release or threat of release under this section, to any other person the liability imposed under this section…”

[42 U.S.C. 9607(e)(1)]

In other words, CERCLA specifically provides that, while you can have such an agreement if you want to, the liability imposed by CERCLA cannot be transferred in this manner. Anyone who meets the definition of “responsible party” will be held liable by EPA.

Responsible Parties can be held liable for the full costs of hazardous substance identification, removal, remediation, health effects studies, environmental effects studies, and any other overhead associated with the Superfund site. There is no “upper limit” on what those costs can be – the sky’s the limit when it comes to Superfund liability.

However…

Even though the EPA will still hold you liable if you are a “responsible party,” that doesn’t mean that you can’t sue to recover costs from someone who contractually offered protection from liability via indemnification or “hold harmless” types of clauses.

The agreement between you and the other party still holds.

If you had a contractual agreement that stipulates your waste management service will assume liability for the clean-up of releases or will cover your court costs if you get sued because of a release, you can still sue them to cover whatever you are expected to pay under CERCLA. CERCLA doesn’t nullify those agreements. The law simply states that you cannot use the language of such an agreement to “get out of” being a responsible party yourself under CERCLA.
 

Convenient, Effective Online EHS Manager Training

Managing site compliance with the many complex EPA programs that affect your business—from the Clean Air and Clean Water Acts to TSCA, EPCRA, CERLCA, and more—is a major challenge. If you’re new to the field or need an update on changing EPA rules, online training is a convenient way to quickly build in-depth expertise.

Check out the latest EPA compliance training options here:
 
Complete Environmental Regulations
Clean Air Act Regulations Online
TSCA Regulations Online
Clean Water Act & SDWA Regulations Online
Superfund and Right-to-Know Act Regulations Online 
 

Tags: CERCLA, environmental compliance, hazardous waste, Superfund

Find a Post

Compliance Archives

Lion - Quotes

Lion provided an excellent introduction to environmental regulations, making the transition to a new career as an EHS specialist less daunting of a task. Drinking from a fire hose when the flow of water is lessened, is much more enjoyable!

Stephanie Weathers

SHE Specialist

Amazing instructor; real-life examples. Lion training gets better every year!

Frank Papandrea

Environmental Manager

Lion's information is very thorough and accurate. Presenter was very good.

Melissa Little

Regulatory Manager

I like the consistency of Lion workshops. The materials are well put together and instructors are top notch!

Kevin Pylka

Permitting, Compliance & Environmental Manager

The instructor made the class enjoyable. He presented in a very knowledgeable, personable manner. Best class I've ever attended. Will take one again.

John Nekoloff

Environmental Compliance Manager

The instructor was probably the best I ever had! He made the class enjoyable, was humorous at times, and very knowledgeable.

Mary Sue Michon

Environmental Administrator

Well designed and thorough program. Excellent summary of requirements with references. Inclusion of regulations in hard copy form, as well as full electronic with state pertinent regulations included is a great bonus!

Oscar Fisher

EHS Manager

If I need thorough training or updating, I always use Lion. Lion is always the best in both instruction and materials.

Bryce Parker

EHS Manager

I think LION does an excellent job of any training they do. Materials provided are very useful to my day-to-day work activities.

Pamela Embody

EHS Specialist

Excellent. I learned more in two days with Lion than at a 5-day program I took with another provider.

Francisco Gallardo

HES Technician

Download Our Latest Whitepaper

Hazardous materials shipment rejections bear a big cost. Use this guide to end operational and logistical disruptions that severely impact your bottom line.

Latest Whitepaper

By submitting your phone number, you agree to receive recurring marketing and training text messages. Consent to receive text messages is not required for any purchases. Text STOP at any time to cancel. Message and data rates may apply. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.