Court Invalidates Parts of EPA's 2015 Definition of Solid Waste Rule

Posted on 8/14/2017 by Roger Marks

A D.C. Circuit Court last month invalidated parts of EPA’s 2015 update to the Definition of Solid Waste (DSW) pertaining to the reclamation of hazardous secondary materials.

When it took effect in 2015, the revised DSW made myriad updates to the hazardous waste rules, among them imposing new requirements for hazardous waste generators and facilities that accept waste shipments for the purpose of reclamation. Called the “Verified Recycler Exclusion,” the updated requirements replaced the 2008 iteration of the exclusion—the “Transfer-based Exclusion.”

RCRA Reclamation Exclusions Background

Both the 2008 Transfer-based Exclusion and its replacement, the 2015 Verified Recycler Exclusion, impact which hazardous secondary materials may be excluded from the definition of solid waste. If a material is not a solid waste, it cannot be a hazardous waste. This gives generators a clear incentive to recycle.

What Changed Between the 2008 and 2015 DSW Rules?

drums-in-truck.jpgUnder the 2008 transfer-based exclusion, hazardous waste generators were required to make a “reasonable effort” to ensure any facility to which they sent their waste for reclamation would, in fact, properly and legitimately reclaim the material.

Receiving facilities, in turn, were required to notify EPA of their intention to perform the reclamation activity.

Under the revised 2015 Definition of Solid Waste, EPA instead requires receiving facilities to obtain a variance from US EPA (or an authorized State Agency) in order to reclaim hazardous secondary materials. Alternatively, facilities can meet this requirement by obtaining or modifying a RCRA permit.  
The 2015 DSW also requires hazardous waste generators to take additional steps to defend against emergency releases. Namely, generators are required to adequately contain their hazardous waste and meet certain emergency preparedness requirements before shipping waste off site to be reclaimed.

What Did the D.C. Court Decide, Exactly?

In its decision, the D.C. Circuit Court upheld the new containment and contingency planning requirements for generators shipping waste to a third party to be reclaimed. However, the court struck down the requirement for receiving facilities to obtain a variance or permit.

If the D.C. Court’s decision is upheld, the 2008 transfer-based exclusion will be reinstituted—but will include the elements of the 2015 Rule that the court upheld.   

RCRA Recycling Legitimacy Factors 

The 2015 DSW also requires generators to comply with four factors in order to capitalize on the exclusions for recycling hazardous secondary materials in any way:
  1. Utility—The recycled material must provide a useful contribution to the process or intermediate or serve as an effective substitute for a commercial product.
  2. Value—The recycling process must yield a valuable product or intermediate.  
  3. Management—The material must be managed as a valuable commodity.
  4. Comparable—Levels of hazardous constituents in the recycled product must be comparable to or lower than similar existing products.
RCRA_recycling.gifIndustry groups challenged the third and fourth factors on this list. The D.C. Court struck down the fourth factor—“Comparable”—because in order to compare a recycled product to an existing commodity, we must know the level of hazardous constituents in the existing commodity. Because this hazard information is not always available for commercial products, the court deemed this requirement to be unreasonable.

As for factor three, which requires facilities to manage materials destined for recycling as “valuable commodities”—the court determined this requirement to be reasonable—especially given the alternatives EPA authorizes in the Final Rule—and upheld it. 

Given this decision, whether the 2008 or the 2015 recycling legitimacy criteria will remain in place is unclear. It will likely depend on whether the court’s decision is upheld and how it is implemented.

Why Is This RCRA Recycling Stuff So Confusing?

To understand one major reason that RCRA recycling rules are so involved and confusing for generators and Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities (TSDFs), we have to go back to 1985—the year EPA crafted its first major update to the Definition of Solid Waste. In that Rule, EPA equated reclamation with discarding hazardous waste—allowing for no exclusion.

EPA was quickly challenged on this by industry groups who saw reclamation as a legitimate recycling activity and lost in the 1987 case American Mining Congress v. EPA. For the last thirty years, EPA has tried to “fix” the initial overreach by promulgating a number of specific exclusions for certain recycling activities.

RCRA Recycling Reliefs Webinar

Confused? Join us for the RCRA Recycling Reliefs Webinar on September 7 for a piece-by-piece break down of your responsibilities for recycling hazardous secondary materials—including updates in the 2015 Definition of Solid Waste Final Rule and the implications of this D.C. Court opinion. Can't join us live? Click the link above to check out the new, self-paced RCRA Recycling Online Course.

Find out how capitalizing on the latest RCRA recycling exclusions can help your site streamline your efforts and save money on waste transport, disposal, and liability costs! 

RCRA Manager Training Now Updated

rcraclipboard.JPGThe 2015 DSW isn’t the only RCRA update hazardous waste generators are grappling lately. In 2016, EPA finalized the “Hazardous Waste Generator Improvements Rule,” which made major changes to the rules for managing hazardous waste on site.    

Lion’s comprehensive RCRA manager online courses are now updated to reflect the historic updates RCRA updates in this Final Rule—from new contingency planning requirements to updated hazardous waste container labels, new exclusions, re-shuffled generator standards, and much more.  Complete either course below to meet your annual EPA training mandate (40 CFR 262.17) and be confident you’re ready when your state adopts the new RCRA rules.

RCRA Hazardous Waste Management (Initial)
RCRA Hazardous Waste Management—Refresher 

Plus, when you enroll now, you get a full year of Lion Membership for fast answers from EHS compliance experts, exclusive updates and content, and discounts on select training events. 

Tags: DSW, EPA, hazardous waste, new rules, recycling

Find a Post

Compliance Archives

Lion - Quotes

The instructor was very very informative, helpful, understandable and pleasant. This course answered many questions I had, being new to this industry.

Frances Mona

Shipping Manager

Lion was very extensive. There was a lot of things that were covered that were actually pertaining to what I do and work with. Great Job. I will be coming back in three years!

Tony Petrik

Hazmat Shipping Professional

The online course was well thought out and organized, with good interaction between the student and the course.

Larry Ybarra

Material Release Agent

The instructor took a rather drab set of topics and brought them to life with realistic real-life examples.

Tom Berndt

HSE Coordinator

Very good. I have always appreciated the way Lion Tech develops, presents and provides training and materials.

John Troy

Environmental Specialist

Lion's information is very thorough and accurate. Presenter was very good.

Melissa Little

Regulatory Manager

I attended training from another provider and learned absolutely nothing. Lion is much better. Hands down.

Nicole Eby

Environmental Specialist

The instructor made the class enjoyable. He presented in a very knowledgeable, personable manner. Best class I've ever attended. Will take one again.

John Nekoloff

Environmental Compliance Manager

I was recently offered an opportunity to take my training through another company, but I politely declined. I only attend Lion Technology workshops.

Stephanie Gilliam

Material Production/Logistics Manager

Lion Technology workshops are amazing!! You always learn so much, and the instructors are fantastic.

Dorothy Rurak

Environmental Specialist

Download Our Latest Whitepaper

Four key considerations to help you maximize the convenience and quality of your experience with online training.

Latest Whitepaper

By submitting your phone number, you agree to receive recurring marketing and training text messages. Consent to receive text messages is not required for any purchases. Text STOP at any time to cancel. Message and data rates may apply. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.