OSHA Expands Penalty Policy for First Time Since 1990

Posted on 1/26/2023 by Nick Waldron

An aggressive OSHA penalty policy is expanding to cover a wider range of employer health and safety violations in about 55 days. 

“Instance-by-instance” or "IBI" penalty adjustments are a tool that OSHA enforcement personnel can use to cite and assess penalties for each instance of a workplace health & safety violation separately. Since introducing the policy in 1990, OSHA has used instance-by-instance citations for only the most egregious, willful employer violations.

OSHA now aims to apply IBI penalties to “achieve an additional deterrent effect” for noncompliance with some of the most frequently violated Standards in general industry, maritime, agriculture, and construction industry workplaces, according to an agency memo and a statement from OSHA’s Administrator.

The supercharged enforcement policy may now be applied to “high-gravity serious violations” of requirements related to:

  • Falls
  • Machine guarding
  • Respiratory protection,
  • Permit required confined spaces,
  • Lockout/tagout, and
  • Trenching. 

Other-than-serious violations related to recordkeeping will also be considered for instance-by-instance citations from OSHA. The policy expansion was announced on January 26 and will take effect sixty days later, on March 27, 2023. 

What is an OSHA Instance-By-Instance Citation?

Normally if an OSHA inspector discovers multiple similar violations at a workplace, or a series of violations that contribute to the same unsafe condition, those violations could be grouped together into one citation.

When OSHA applies the instance-by-instance penalty adjustment, those same related violations are cited separately, instead.

Instead of one citation for failure to have lockout/tagout controls when required, OSHA may cite the employer separately for each and every machine that lacks hazardous energy controls.

Instead of one citation for failure to provide respiratory protection training or complete required medical evaluations, OSHA may cite the employer separately for each employee who was not trained and evaluated. The result is more citations, adding up to more civil penaltiespenalties that increase annually to keep pace with inflation

When Will OSHA Use the New Policy?

OSHA officers are encouraged to apply instance-by-instance penalty adjustments to deter employers from endangering their workers or otherwise violating OSHA Standards.

According to OSHA, the decision to utilize IBI citations should normally consider one or more of these factors:

  • The employer has received a willful, repeat, or failure to abate violation within the past five years where that classification is current;
  • The employer has failed to report a fatality, inpatient hospitalization, amputation, or loss of an eye pursuant to the requirements of 29 CFR 1904.39;
  • The proposed citations are related to a fatality/catastrophe; or
  • The proposed recordkeeping citations are related to injury or illness(es) that occurred as a result of a serious hazard.

It should be noted that the utilizing the policy is not all-or-nothing—if the employer has multiple violations, OSHA may choose which violations to cite instance-by-instance and which to group.

When issued to employers, instance-by-instance citations will be subject to an extensive review process. If approved, the IBI citations will be issued and OSHA will issue a press release to serve as a further deterrent to noncompliance.

Workplace Safety Training for Frequently Cited Hazards

Beef up your knowledge of the OSHA Standards that may now be subject to instance-by-instance penalties.

Lion’s online OSHA safety training covers key requirements for employers and can help to satisfy employee training requirements found in many of OSHA’s most broadly applicable Standards.

Check out for a full range of convenient online safety training that includes Lion Membership for ongoing regulatory compliance support.

Try the 10 Hour Training for General Industry workers to get a sense of the most common hazards in general industry, and what OSHA requires from employers.

Tags: 29 CFR, enforcement, osha, safety

Find a Post

Compliance Archives

Lion - Quotes

As always, Lion never disappoints

Paul Resley

Environmental Coordinator

Best instructor ever! I was going to take my DOT training w/a different provider, but based on this presentation, I will also be doing my DOT training w/Lion!

Donna Moot

Hazardous Waste Professional

I really enjoy your workshops. Thank you for such a great program and all the help Lion has provided me over the years!

George Chatman

Hazardous Material Pharmacy Technician

Lion's information is very thorough and accurate. Presenter was very good.

Melissa Little

Regulatory Manager

I really enjoyed this training. Even after years on both sides of the comprehension coin, I find myself still learning! The quality of the delivery exceeded much of the training I have received in the past.

Neil Ozonur

Safety Officer

The instructor was very engaging and helped less experienced people understand the concepts.

Steve Gall

Safety Leader

Lion was very extensive. There was a lot of things that were covered that were actually pertaining to what I do and work with. Great Job. I will be coming back in three years!

Tony Petrik

Hazmat Shipping Professional

Lion does a great job summarizing and communicating complicated EH&S-related regulations.

Michele Irmen

Sr. Environmental Engineer

Lion's course was superior to others I have taken in the past. Very clear in the presentation and the examples helped to explain the content presented.

George Bersik

Hazardous Waste Professional

Very witty instructor, made the long times sitting bearable. One of the few training courses I can say I actually enjoyed.

John Hutchinson

Senior EHS Engineer

Download Our Latest Whitepaper

Shipping papers are a crucial part of safely shipping hazardous materials. See the top 5 mistakes shippers make on shipping papers, and how to avoid them.

Latest Whitepaper

By submitting your phone number, you agree to receive recurring marketing and training text messages. Consent to receive text messages is not required for any purchases. Text STOP at any time to cancel. Message and data rates may apply. View our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.